On this page
- Long Island SEO firms compared side by side
- 16 top SEO companies in Long Island, from Melville agencies to South Shore specialists
- Nassau and Suffolk by the numbers
- From Garden City to the Hamptons: Long Island search geography
- How much Nassau and Suffolk businesses spend on SEO
- Contractors, storm repair and Long Island home services
- Law firms and medical practices in Nassau and Suffolk
- The East End season, wineries and summer tourism
- English and Spanish searches across Long Island
- New York privacy, advertising and review rules
- Summer, back to school and the Long Island calendar
- Map pack visibility across Nassau and Suffolk
- Long Island sectors where rankings are hardest to win
- Helping Long Island businesses appear in AI answers
- Long Island options: internal hire, freelancer or SEO firm
- Eight questions to ask Long Island SEO firms
- Long Island SEO offers to approach carefully
- Your first quarter with a top SEO company in Long Island
- Standards each Long Island SEO firm met
- Sources
- FAQs
The first pick of the top SEO companies in Long Island is Top SEO Agency, since it covers Nassau and Suffolk local search with full SEO, GEO, AEO and AI SEO run by senior specialists, plus a written plan within 1 business day. For other needs, SEO Image suits firms wanting a Melville office with reputation management, Thrive Internet Marketing Agency suits franchises and multi location brands, and Mimvi SEO suits firms needing map visibility in specific towns. Many Long Island small businesses budget $2,500 to $6,000 a month.
Long Island is a huge suburban market that behaves like dozens of small towns. Nassau and Suffolk counties are home to nearly three million people, large hospital systems, the Hauppauge Industrial Park, a dense network of law firms, contractors and medical practices, and a seasonal East End economy in the Hamptons and North Fork. Searches are town by town, from Garden City to Patchogue, so the top SEO companies in Long Island need precise local SEO, trust building content and a plan for AI generated answers.
Share your site and targets, and we will send transparent SEO pricing in 1 business day.
Get my SEO quote Chat on WhatsAppLong Island SEO firms compared side by side
Shortlist three or four firms from the table and request written proposals.
| Company | Main strength | Best fit | Key services |
|---|---|---|---|
| Top SEO Agency | Full-funnel SEO, GEO, AEO and AI SEO | Long Island law firms, practices, contractors, East End hospitality brands and manufacturers that need town level local, organic and AI visibility | SEO, GEO, AEO, AI SEO |
| Novlers | SEO, ads and rebuilds from one team | Long Island legal, healthcare, automotive and travel brands wanting SEO, ads and a new site from one team | SEO, AI SEO, Local SEO, Ecommerce SEO |
| SEO Image | Melville office with reputation work | Firms wanting a Melville office with reputation management | SEO, Reputation management, Local SEO, Content |
| Thrive Internet Marketing Agency | Franchise and multi location SEO | Franchises and multi location brands | SEO, Franchise SEO, PPC, Content marketing |
| Mimvi SEO | Town level Business Profile SEO | Firms needing map visibility in specific towns | Google Business Profile, Technical SEO audits, Citation building, Local content |
| Upside Business Consultants | Quality guideline led SEO | Firms wanting quality guideline led SEO | SEO, Content strategy, White hat link building |
| Active Web Group | Local web design and SEO | Firms wanting web design and SEO locally | SEO, Web design, Digital marketing |
| Local Media Solutions | Local search for nearby customers | Owners who rely on nearby customers | Local SEO, SEO, Google Business Profile |
| MIS Services | Town level and industrial park SEO | Firms targeting many towns or the Hauppauge Industrial Park | Local SEO, B2B SEO, AI search |
| Design Me Marketing | Professional services SEO | Professional services firms | SEO, Web design, Content |
| Lead Marketing Strategies | Established high volume agency | Firms wanting an established, high volume agency | SEO, Digital marketing, Lead generation |
| Benjamin Marc | Long running local agency | Companies wanting a long running local partner | SEO, Web design, Digital marketing |
| KickAds | South Shore option | South Shore Suffolk businesses | SEO, Local SEO, Paid ads |
| Direct Response Group | Response focused marketing | Firms focused on measurable responses | SEO, Direct response marketing, Lead generation |
| Network Handlers | IT and web with SEO | Firms wanting IT and web support with SEO | SEO, Web design, IT services |
| NewSunSEO | Smaller SEO firm option | Owners comparing smaller SEO firms | SEO, Local SEO, Content |
16 top SEO companies in Long Island, from Melville agencies to South Shore specialists
We profile the top SEO companies in Long Island below, with a quick read on strengths and fit.
Top SEO Agency
Top SEO Agency is a full range SEO and GEO company that helps Long Island businesses rank in Google results, win the map pack town by town across Nassau and Suffolk and earn citations in AI answers, using solid technical foundations, hyperlocal content and links from New York media and directories. It covers technical SEO, on-page SEO, local SEO, national SEO, SEO content writing and link building, together with GEO, AEO, AI SEO and work on Google AI Mode, ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. Law offices and contractors consider it a top SEO company in Long Island for crowded local searches, and practices and manufacturers call it a top SEO agency for Long Island businesses and one of the best SEO companies on Long Island for senior-level SEO at a lower cost than most Long Island agencies. Senior specialists manage every account, a written plan arrives within 1 business day, and monthly reports connect rankings to calls, consultations, estimates and signed work.
Long Island search is local to a degree that surprises newcomers: a roofer in Massapequa competes in a different map pack from one in Smithtown, and East End businesses see demand swing with the summer season. The first 30 days usually cover a technical and speed audit, SHIELD Act aware tracking, Google Business Profile cleanup for each office, keyword research by town and hamlet in English and Spanish, and a plan for pages covering places such as Garden City, Huntington, Hauppauge, Patchogue and the Hamptons. Calls are booked in Eastern Time, and AI answer checks for ChatGPT and Gemini run from the first month.
Novlers
Novlers is a full-funnel digital marketing agency, and its senior team manages SEO, Google Ads, social media, content and ecommerce marketing together. Its search work joins technical audits, on page fixes, local listings and outreach led link building with AI SEO for answers in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Mode.
Long Island law practices, clinics, dealerships and East End travel businesses can add Google Ads, CRO and WordPress or Shopify builds through the same people when a relaunch is due.
SEO Image
SEO Image is a New York SEO and online reputation management agency with offices in Manhattan and in Melville on Broadhollow Road, serving Nassau and Suffolk businesses.
It works with professionals, ecommerce companies, healthcare practices, law firms, restaurants, real estate firms and contractors.
Thrive Internet Marketing Agency
Thrive Internet Marketing Agency offers Long Island SEO for small, mid sized and large businesses, including franchise SEO, keyword research, link building, PPC, content marketing, web design and conversion optimisation.
Franchises and multi location brands wanting SEO and paid search together may want a proposal.
Clients across Long Island and New York
Mimvi SEO
Mimvi SEO is a Long Island agency focused on Google Business Profile rankings, technical SEO audits, citation building and location based content for companies in Huntington, Garden City, Melville, Smithtown and Babylon.
Businesses that need map pack visibility in specific towns may want a proposal.
Upside Business Consultants
Upside Business Consultants is a Long Island SEO company with offices in Hauppauge and Roslyn that builds content strategy around Google's Search Quality Guidelines and white hat tactics.
Businesses that value a thorough, process driven approach may find it a fit.
Active Web Group
Active Web Group is a full service agency based in Hauppauge on Long Island, listed by Expertise.com among the best SEO agencies serving Huntington.
Businesses wanting web design and SEO from one local team may want a quote.
Local Media Solutions
Local Media Solutions is a Melville company that operates under the name SEO Company Long Island and focuses on local search for Long Island businesses.
Owners who depend on nearby customers may want to compare its plan.
MIS Services
MIS Services is a Lindenhurst based Long Island SEO company that builds town level strategies, with dedicated B2B playbooks for the Hauppauge Industrial Park and attention to Google Maps and AI search.
Businesses that need to rank across many Long Island towns may want a proposal.
Design Me Marketing
Design Me Marketing is a Long Island agency that local directories describe as a documented professional services specialist.
Accountants, lawyers and advisers may want to see its approach.
Lead Marketing Strategies
Lead Marketing Strategies is an established, high volume Long Island agency listed among Expertise.com's top SEO agencies for Huntington.
Businesses wanting an established local agency with a large client base may want a quote.
Benjamin Marc
Benjamin Marc is one of Long Island's long running digital agencies, described in local directories as a two decade institution.
Companies wanting an experienced local partner may want to talk to it.
KickAds
KickAds is a Bay Shore agency that gives South Shore Suffolk County businesses a nearby SEO option outside the Melville and Hauppauge clusters.
Owners along the South Shore may value working with a team close by.
Clients across the South Shore and Suffolk County
Direct Response Group
Direct Response Group is a Melville agency with more than twenty years of operating history, listed in Long Island SEO directories.
Businesses focused on measurable responses may want to see its reporting.
Network Handlers
Network Handlers is a Melville company listed by Expertise.com among SEO agencies serving Huntington.
Businesses wanting IT and web support alongside SEO may find it convenient.
NewSunSEO
NewSunSEO is an SEO company with a Long Island office and a second location in Myrtle Beach.
Long Island owners comparing smaller SEO firms may want to include it.
Clients across Long Island and beyond
Nassau and Suffolk by the numbers
The US Census Bureau counted about 1.4 million people in Nassau County and 1.5 million in Suffolk County in 2020, close to three million residents in total. Long Island Association research highlights healthcare, education, retail and advanced manufacturing as major employers.
StatCounter shows Google handling most US searches, with Bing feeding Copilot. Long Islanders mostly start with Google Search, Maps and AI features on their phones, often while commuting on the LIRR.
Hamlets and villages
Long Island has hundreds of hamlets and villages, and people search with those exact names.
High value households
Affluent buyers compare providers carefully, so detailed service pages and reviews carry extra weight.
From Garden City to the Hamptons: Long Island search geography
Town pages help because the map pack changes from one hamlet to the next, and a business that ranks in Huntington may be invisible in Commack.
Garden City, Mineola and Hempstead
County offices, courts, hospitals and law firms compete for professional searches in central Nassau.
North Shore Nassau
Great Neck, Manhasset and Roslyn residents search for medical specialists, private schools and premium services.
Huntington and Melville
Offices, restaurants and corporate parks along Route 110 drive B2B and dining searches.
Hauppauge and Smithtown
The Hauppauge Industrial Park and surrounding towns create demand for B2B services, contractors and healthcare.
South Shore towns
Massapequa, Babylon, Bay Shore and Patchogue compete for home services, marinas, restaurants and family care.
The East End
The Hamptons, Montauk and the North Fork see huge summer demand for rentals, restaurants, wineries and home services.
How much Nassau and Suffolk businesses spend on SEO
Long Island rates sit just below Manhattan but above most suburban markets. Typical monthly ranges in 2026:
| Business type | Monthly retainer (USD) | What it usually covers |
|---|---|---|
| Single location trade, salon or practice | 1,000 to 2,500 | Google Business Profile, town pages, reviews, citations |
| Growing small business | 2,500 to 6,000 | Technical fixes, content, links, monthly reporting |
| Online store | 5,000 to 15,000 | Category and product SEO, schema, feed strategy |
| Law firm or multi location practice | 6,000 to 20,000 | Practice area pages, town pages, digital PR |
| Manufacturer or regional brand | 10,000 to 40,000+ | National reach, enterprise reporting, AI search tracking |
| One time technical audit | 3,000 to 25,000 | Depends on site size and depth |
For the deliverables behind each Nassau and Suffolk price band, see our SEO pricing guide.
Contractors, storm repair and Long Island home services
Older housing stock, coastal weather and high property values keep roofing, siding, HVAC, plumbing, landscaping and remodelling in constant demand. Nor'easters and hurricane season add generator, tree removal and water damage searches.
Licence numbers on every page
Home improvement contractors licensed by Nassau County Consumer Affairs or Suffolk County should show licence numbers, which also builds trust.
Town by town service pages
Separate pages for the towns you actually serve help contractors appear across both counties.
Seasonal planning
Storm and seasonal pages should be indexed before peak months. See landscaping SEO and plumber SEO.
Law firms and medical practices in Nassau and Suffolk
Personal injury, matrimonial, real estate closing, estate planning and criminal defence firms compete hard across Mineola, Garden City, Hauppauge and Riverhead. New York attorney advertising rules require careful wording and labelling, so legal pages need review.
Large hospital systems and thousands of private practices compete for patients across the island. Provider profiles, insurance details, location pages and genuine reviews drive appointments. See law firm SEO and healthcare SEO.
The East End season, wineries and summer tourism
Every summer the Hamptons, Montauk, Fire Island and the North Fork draw visitors and second home owners searching for restaurants, rentals, wineries, boat charters, beach services and home maintenance. Many businesses earn most of their revenue in a few months.
Pages for summer services, events and opening hours, published and indexed by spring, help East End businesses catch early research. See winery SEO and hotel SEO.
English and Spanish searches across Long Island
Communities such as Brentwood, Hempstead, Central Islip and Freeport have large Spanish speaking populations, and many residents search in Spanish for legal, healthcare, home services and immigration help.
Native Spanish pages, Spanish Business Profile descriptions and reviews in Spanish widen reach. Language versions should be linked with hreflang tags.
New York privacy, advertising and review rules
SHIELD Act
The New York Attorney General enforces the SHIELD Act, which requires reasonable safeguards for personal data collected through forms and tools.
Attorney advertising
New York rules on lawyer advertising affect how legal sites present results, testimonials and labels.
Honest reviews
The FTC rule on fake reviews bans buying or faking reviews.
Summer, back to school and the Long Island calendar
Memorial Day through Labor Day drives the East End economy and lifts searches for beaches, boats, rentals and outdoor dining. Back to school, the holidays and spring home improvement season move other categories.
Storm season, tax season for accountants and the spring real estate market also shift demand. Seasonal pages should be indexed several weeks before each peak.
Map pack visibility across Nassau and Suffolk
Each real office needs its own Google Business Profile that follows Google's guidelines, with the correct hamlet or village, categories, hours and photos. Service area businesses should list only towns they truly serve.
Consistent NAP details across Yelp, Apple Maps, Bing Places, the BBB and industry directories, plus genuine reviews, support rankings. Our local SEO checklist walks through the steps.
Long Island sectors where rankings are hardest to win
Legal
Injury, matrimonial and real estate firms compete for costly searches.
Healthcare and dental
Practices compete for patients across both counties. See dental SEO.
Home services
Contractors compete for repair and remodelling work.
Real estate
Agents compete for buyers and sellers in high value markets. See real estate SEO.
Hospitality and wineries
East End venues compete during a short summer season.
Manufacturing and B2B
Hauppauge firms compete for national buyers. See manufacturing SEO.
Helping Long Island businesses appear in AI answers
Long Islanders now ask ChatGPT, Gemini or Google's AI features for a matrimonial lawyer in Mineola, a roofer in Smithtown or a winery on the North Fork. These tools pull from a small pool of sources, so strong rankings do not guarantee a mention.
Quotable facts
Towns served, licences, hours, prices and credentials in short sentences are easy for AI tools to reuse. Our AI SEO services structure pages this way.
Local news and directories
Coverage in Newsday, Long Island Business News and trusted directories gives AI systems outside confirmation.
Schema markup
LocalBusiness, LegalService, Dentist and Winery structured data summarise pages for machines.
A monthly AI review
Asking the main assistants about your business each month reveals gaps rank trackers miss. See ChatGPT SEO.
Long Island options: internal hire, freelancer or SEO firm
Long Island has many freelancers and small agencies, so the best model depends on budget and the range of skills required.
An internal hire
Hospital systems, large law firms and manufacturers often hire SEO staff who work with marketing and compliance teams.
A freelancer
A single office practice or trade can do well with one experienced freelancer focused on Maps and reviews.
An SEO firm
When technical work, town pages, links and AI visibility all matter, a firm brings several specialists. Read how to hire an SEO expert.
Eight questions to ask Long Island SEO firms
- 1Which Long Island clients in my field have you worked with, and can I call one?
- 2Who will do the work each month?
- 3What will be delivered in the first 90 days?
- 4How will calls and forms be tracked under New York privacy rules?
- 5Which towns and hamlets will you target first?
- 6Where will links come from, and are they local?
- 7How will you track mentions in AI assistants?
- 8Will we own every account and page if we stop?
Compare the replies using our guide to choosing an SEO company.
Long Island SEO offers to approach carefully
Most Long Island firms work honestly, but some offers deserve caution.
Promised first place rankings
Guarantees ignore how Google works.
Review schemes
Buying or faking reviews breaks FTC rules and Google policy.
Copy and paste town pages
Near identical hamlet pages can be ignored or penalised.
Long contracts without reviews
Lengthy terms with no performance check remove your leverage.
Your first quarter with a top SEO company in Long Island
- 1Weeks 1 to 2: technical and speed audit, privacy aware call and form tracking, keyword research by town in English and Spanish.
- 2Weeks 3 to 4: Business Profile cleanup for each office, licence and credential details and rewrites of the highest value pages.
- 3Month 2: town, service and practice area pages, schema markup and internal links.
- 4Month 3: links from Long Island media and directories, review requests, AI answer checks and a report on calls, consultations and jobs.
New York readers can also compare our list of top SEO companies in New York.
Standards each Long Island SEO firm met
Long Island has a dense cluster of SEO firms, and most published lists are written by one of them.
To compile this list of top SEO firms in Long Island we reviewed Expertise.com and other directories, Long Island SEO roundups published by agencies and review sites, the Long Island service pages of New York agencies, and the firms that ChatGPT and Google's AI features suggest for SEO on Long Island. Nearly every roundup ranked its own author first, so we set aside their positions, review counts and award claims and described each firm from its own service description or neutral directory text.
Novlers shares ownership with Top SEO Agency.
A Nassau or Suffolk presence
Each firm on the list has a Long Island office or publishes services specifically for Long Island clients.
Clear SEO services
We kept firms whose pages or directory profiles describe their local, technical, content or reputation work.
Different sizes and styles
The list covers national agencies, long running local firms and small town focused specialists.
No borrowed scores
Ratings, review counts and awards from other lists were left out.
A named best fit
Each profile says which kind of business it suits.
Sources
Neeraj has more than five years of SEO experience and has led SEO teams at top SEO agencies in India. He specializes in technical SEO, local SEO, content strategy and AI search visibility, and he reviews every company on this list against the same criteria and updates the page as companies change their services.